What’s the Nuttiest Argument You’ve Heard From Someone Who Thinks It’s Healthy to Be a Carnivore?

The world of diets and nutrition is no stranger to a broad array of beliefs, some rooted in science, while others are… well, a tad more eccentric.

Particularly, discussions around plant-based diets versus carnivore diets can yield some truly unique arguments.

Let’s explore some of the most unconventional statements made by carnivore enthusiasts.


A recent meme has surfaced suggesting that certain biochemical terms from plants, like “OXALATES,” are part of a plant’s defense mechanism, implying that plants are trying to harm or kill humans.

The argument goes: “Plants don’t want you to eat them, they are trying to kill you. That’s why they make OXALATES which cause you harm.”

The counterargument to this is twofold: firstly, this claim is scientifically unsound, and secondly, by that logic, animals would also prefer not to be consumed, which is evident when they perceive humans as threats.


One peculiar belief circulating in carnivore communities is that a meat-only diet leads to minimal or no waste elimination.

The argument suggests that when you only consume meat, you absorb all the nutrients, leaving no residue to be excreted. Contrarily, when you eat other foods, you need to eliminate the non-nutrient parts.

This theory insinuates that an all-meat diet is the optimal health choice because it’s the most efficient.

However, many health experts would question the validity and health implications of such a stance.


Another intriguing point of contention revolves around dairy.

Some individuals argue that non-dairy milks increase estrogen levels in the body.

Ironically, these individuals advocate for raw milk consumption, which, in reality, contains significant amounts of animal-derived estrogen, unlike plant-based milks that contain phytoestrogens.

There’s a hint of irony here, especially when the same individuals voice concerns over the potential feminizing effects of plant-based diets.


In the realm of unconventional beliefs, some have even posited that the concept of global warming was fabricated by companies like Beyond Meat to boost the sales of plant-based burgers.

Such conspiracy theories, though amusing, highlight the lengths to which some will go to discredit plant-based diets.


A classic argument that often resurfaces is the belief that meat consumption was responsible for the evolutionary growth of the human brain.

Proponents believe that our ancestors’ meat consumption was a pivotal factor in our cognitive development.

While there are theories around diet and brain evolution, simplifying it to just meat consumption overlooks other significant factors and is far from conclusive.

In conclusion, while dietary choices are personal and varied, it’s essential to approach any argument or belief with a critical lens, especially when they border on the outlandish.

Whether one chooses a plant-based diet, a carnivore diet, or something in between, it’s crucial to make informed decisions backed by credible research and not just catchy memes or anecdotes.

But what do you think? Have you come across any quirky arguments or theories that left you scratching your head?

Or perhaps you have a unique perspective on the ones mentioned above?

Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below.

Your voice matters, and we’d love to hear from you. Dive into the discussion and let’s keep the conversation going!

I am Jennifer, a fervent animal lover, and a dedicated vegan. Am the person behind the veganoga.com. I offer insights, advice, and personal stories that have inspired many in their journey towards a plant-based lifestyle. My journey into veganism has also been coupled with a love for writing. I used this passion to share my vegan experiences, to educate others about the benefits of plant-based living, and to advocate for animal rights. Find out more about me on the about page.

Leave a Comment